Advances, Systems and Applications
Table 11 Format of the form for extracting the data for the analysis of the primary studies
Form data | Explanation | Values |
|---|---|---|
Generic information | Generic information about each of the primary studies | Not applicable |
Responsible researcher | Name of the expert analysing the primary study. | Juncal Alonso, Valentina Casola, Leire Orue-Echevarria, Ana Isabel Torre |
Accepted/rejected | Inclusion or rejection decision. | Accepted/Rejected |
Paper Id | Paper Id | 1–114 |
Paper Title | Full title of the primary study | NA |
Abstract | Abstract of the primary study | NA |
Key words | Key words defined by the primary study | NA |
Abstract | Abstract from the primary study | NA |
Author | Author/Authors | NA |
Year | Year of publication of the primary study | 2006–2020 |
Doi | Digital Object Identifier of the primary study | NA |
Comments | Any relevant comment made by the expert about the primary study | NA |
Source link | Link to the primary study | NA |
Number of citations | Number of citations of the primary study | 1–500 |
Length | Length (number of pages) | 1–50 |
Venue Type | Type of the venue where the primary study was published | Conference, Journal, Book |
Venue | Name of the venue where the primary study was published | NA |
Research Type | Type of the research corresponding to the primary study | Evaluation research, Experience paper, Opinion paper, Philosophical paper, Solution proposal, Validation research |
Case Study | Type of the case study where the primary study was validated | Academic case study (e.g. with students), Action research, Controlled experiment with practitioners, Industrial Case study, Laboratory experiments (machine or human), Mathematical analysis and proof of properties, Practitioner targeted survey Prototyping Simulation as an empirical method |
Information for RQ1/RQ2 | ||
RQ1/RQ2: Meaning of the term multi-cloud generic | Definition of the term multi-cloud (if any) in the primary study | NA |
RQ1/RQ2: Meaning of the term multi-cloud native application | Definition of the term multi-cloud native application (if any) in the primary study | NA |
Information for RQ3 | ||
RQ3: multi-cloud by design: architectural patterns | Multi-cloud architectural patterns identified in the primary study | NA |
RQ3:multi-cloud by design: technologies | Technologies related to multi-cloud cited by the primary study | NA |
RQ3:multi-cloud by design: standards | Standards related to multi-cloud cited by the primary study | NA |
RQ3:multi-cloud by design: process | Processes followed/identified by the primary study for the design of multi-cloud applications | NA |
Information for RQ5 | ||
RQ5: Main security threats and countermeasures in multi-cloud native applications | Security threats and countermeasures identified by the primary study affecting in multi-cloud native applications | NA |
Information for RQ6 | ||
RQ6: Future trends in multi-cloud /hybrid cloud | Future research trends related to the design and operation of multi cloud native applications identified in the primary study | NA |
Information for RQ4 | ||
RQ4: multi-cloud challenges: design | Design challenges cited in the primary study for multi-cloud native applications | NA |
RQ4: multi-cloud challenges: development & execution | Development and execution challenges cited in the primary study for multi-cloud native applications | NA |
RQ4: multi-cloud challenges: operation | Operation challenges cited in the primary study for multi-cloud native applications | NA |
multi-cloud benefits general | Benefits of multi-cloud native applications identified by the primary study | NA |
multi-cloud drawbacks: general | Drawbacks of multi-cloud native applications identified by the primary study | NA |